Invisible Control

Appendix

Glossary

Every technical term used on this site, in plain words. These definitions are the single source of truth: the tooltips elsewhere read from this file, so a term is never defined twice and never defined differently in two places.

Achievement societyHan
A society where the subject exploits itself voluntarily and experiences the exploitation as freedom.
Activity inhibitionMcClelland
A steady disposition to restrain your own impulses. In McClelland’s research it is the variable that decides whether a strong drive for influence turns useful or destructive.
Administrative researchLazarsfeld
Research done for an institution to improve how it operates. Lazarsfeld named it, in English, while running exactly that kind of bureau.
Assumptive worldParkes, Janoff-Bulman
The background beliefs you run on without ever stating them: that the world is roughly benevolent, that it makes sense, that you are worth something. What breaks in a shock is usually this, not a fact.
Bare lifeAgamben
A human reduced to biological existence alone, with no political standing, exposed to a power that can dispose of them without it counting as a crime.
BiopoliticsFoucault
Government aimed at populations as biological life: birth rates, mortality, health, hygiene. The old sovereign right was to take life. This one is to make live and let die.
Civil societyGramsci
Schools, churches, press, publishers, unions and cultural life: everything outside the government that shapes what people take for granted. Where consent is manufactured.
Common senseGramsci
The unexamined inherited worldview most people carry: fragments of religion, folklore and ruling-class ideas absorbed without checking. Hegemony travels through it.
Convivial toolIllich
A tool anyone can pick up for their own purposes, which makes them more capable rather than more dependent. The bicycle, the library, hand tools.
Correspondence principleBowles and Gintis
School reproduces the workforce through its structure rather than its lessons: hierarchy, alienated work for external reward, competition.
CounterproductivityIllich
An institution past a certain size producing the opposite of what it promises: schools that teach helplessness, transport that consumes the time it saves.
Critical researchLazarsfeld
Research asking what an institution is for and whom it serves. The kind Lazarsfeld could not fund, because it produced nothing countable.
Cultural arbitraryBourdieu
The specific culture of the dominant class, taught in schools as though it were culture itself rather than one culture among several.
Cultural capitalBourdieu
Advantages that are not money: the right vocabulary, familiarity with valued culture, comfort in institutions. It converts into opportunity the way money converts into goods.
Culture industryAdorno and Horkheimer
Mass culture as standardized industrial production that pacifies rather than liberates, and offers pseudo-individuality in place of the real thing.
DecisionismSchmitt
The claim that legal order rests at bottom on a decision by a concrete authority, not on a rule. Rules only work inside a situation somebody first made orderly.
Despotic powerMann
What elites can do without negotiating with anyone. Modern states have less of this than people assume, and it is not the main danger.
Disciplinary powerFoucault
Continuous low-level shaping of bodies and conduct through timetables, ranked rows, inspection and correction. It works on everyone, all the time, and barely looks like power.
Disorienting dilemmaMezirow
An experience that does not fit the way you already make sense of things, so it cannot be filed away and forces you to rebuild the frame instead. The starting point of any real change of mind.
DividualDeleuze
A person split into data attributes and scored in pieces, rather than dealt with as a whole individual.
Docile bodiesFoucault
People made productive and politically harmless at the same time.
Enlightened false consciousnessSloterdijk
Knowing exactly how the thing works and carrying on anyway. Not ignorance, and not hypocrisy either, because nothing is being hidden. Criticism absorbed until it costs nothing.
Fear of freedomFromm, Freire
The pull back toward being told what to do, because freedom brings isolation and the weight of choosing. Fromm argued people flee it into conformity, submission or destructiveness.
Force-of-law without lawAgamben
Binding legal force detached from any actual statute: the power to decide over a life, wearing the form of law and none of its substance.
Friend and enemy distinctionSchmitt
Schmitt’s definition of politics: any genuinely political relation comes down to the possibility of sorting people into friends and enemies.
Goodhart’s Law
When a measure becomes a target, it stops being a good measure. The operational core of what goes wrong with metrics everywhere.
GovernmentalityFoucault
Governing by shaping the choices of free people instead of forcing them. You are not compelled, you are configured to want what keeps the system running.
HabitusBourdieu
The dispositions you absorb growing up, including accent, taste, bearing and how at ease you are with authority. It feels like personality. It is inherited social position.
HegemonyGramsci
Rule by consent rather than by force, where one group’s interests have been accepted by everyone else as plain common sense.
Hidden curriculumJackson
What school teaches through its form rather than its syllabus: wait your turn, be evaluated, accept unequal authority.
Hidden transcriptScott
What subordinates actually say and do out of sight of power, as opposed to the public performance of deference.
Homo sacerAgamben
A figure from archaic Roman law who may be killed but not sacrificed. Outside both human and divine law, and included in the order precisely by being cast out of it.
IatrogenesisIllich
Harm caused by medicine itself, from drug effects and hospital infection up to a culture that has forgotten how to be ill without management.
Illusion of explanatory depthRozenblit and Keil
Believing you understand how something works until you are asked to explain it step by step, at which point the confidence collapses. Recognition of an idea feels like knowledge of it.
Infrastructural powerMann
A state’s capacity to actually reach into society and carry a decision through. Modern states have unprecedented amounts of it.
Iron law of oligarchyMichels
Organizing at all produces a permanent leadership layer whose interests drift away from the members. Derived from the most internally democratic party of its day.
KetmanMiłosz
Professing the required doctrine while keeping a private reservation. The self-division eventually consumes the self it was meant to protect.
LegibilityScott
Simplifying a messy reality so a state can count, map and tax it: surveys, permanent surnames, standard weights, grid cities. Reality then gets reshaped to match the map.
Living within a lieHavel
Performing an assent you do not hold, which pressures the next person to perform it too. Everyone is victim and enforcer at once.
Loading the languageLifton
Thought-terminating clichés that end an argument instead of answering it. The most useful item on Lifton’s list for reading media.
MegamachineMumford
A machine made of human parts organized by authority. The first one built the pyramids, and it had no metal in it.
MētisScott
Practical local knowledge that cannot be written down as a procedure. The thing legibility destroys.
MisrecognitionBourdieu
Accepting that the standard which ranks you low is a fair standard. The student who says "I am just not academic" has done it.
ModulationDeleuze
Control by continuous adjustment rather than by enclosure: rolling assessment, perpetual training, no graduation and no discharge.
Monopoly of knowledgeInnis
The control that forms around whoever masters the dominant medium of an age, and that a new medium breaks.
Moral licensingMonin and Miller
Having established that you are one of the good ones, you do less afterwards rather than more. Understanding a problem can settle the account in your own mind.
NecropoliticsMbembe
Biopolitics seen from the colony, where the power in question is the power to expose people to death rather than to manage their health.
NormFoucault
A standard of normality an institution produces itself, then corrects people against. Discipline does not punish illegality, it corrects deviation.
Organic crisisGramsci
The moment consent breaks down and force has to come out into the open. The old is dying, the new cannot be born, and morbid symptoms appear.
Organic intellectualGramsci
Someone who articulates and organizes the worldview of their own class or group, as opposed to a professor who imagines they stand above all of them.
PanopticonBentham, via Foucault
A prison design where you can always be watched and can never check whether you are being watched now, so you behave as if you are. The uncertainty does the work.
Personalized powerMcClelland
Wanting influence for its own sake, treated as something won at someone else’s expense. Associated with acting on impulse and with decisions that damage the group.
Political formulaMosca
The story a ruling group tells to explain why it should rule: divine right, the will of the people, expertise. Believed sincerely rather than cynically.
Political theologySchmitt
The argument that modern ideas about the state are religious ideas in secular dress. The sovereign suspending law is the political version of a miracle.
Post-totalitarianismHavel
A system that no longer needs anyone to believe it, because ritual compliance is enough to keep it running.
Power/knowledgeFoucault
Producing knowledge about something is at the same time producing power over it. The prison generates criminology, and criminology underwrites the prison.
Procedural justiceTyler
Fairness of the process rather than of the outcome. People comply with authority far more reliably when they judge the procedure fair than when they fear the punishment.
Propaganda modelHerman and Chomsky
Five filters that shape what gets published without anyone giving an order: ownership, advertising, official sources, organized complaint, and an external enemy.
Psychic numbingSlovic
Feeling less as the numbers get bigger. Response does not scale with the size of a harm, it fades, and the fading starts as early as the second victim.
Radical monopolyIllich
One way of meeting a need crowding out every other way until the alternatives become invisible or impossible. Not one brand beating another, but one mode abolishing the rest.
Self-efficacyBandura
Your belief that you can actually do the thing. Built mainly by doing difficult things and succeeding, which means it is trained rather than given.
Social interestAdler
Adler’s name for the sense of being one among others, with something to contribute. He treated it as the mark of health and as the alternative to seeking superiority over people.
Socialized powerMcClelland
Wanting influence in order to get something done for a group. Distinguished from the personal kind not by how much drive there is but by how much restraint sits on top of it.
State of exceptionSchmitt
Emergency suspension of normal law, declared by the authority that also decides an emergency exists.
Striving for superiorityAdler
The drive to rise above others, which Adler read as compensation for felt inferiority rather than as strength. He contrasted it with striving toward completion, which is aimed at a task instead of a person.
Subject-object shiftKegan
Moving from being inside something and unable to see it, to being able to hold it at arm’s length and look at it. You stop being your assumptions and start having them.
Symbolic violenceBourdieu
Domination that works through meaning rather than force, and that the dominated accept as legitimate. It succeeds only because it is not seen as violence.
System justificationJost
The documented tendency to defend and rationalize the existing order, sometimes more strongly the worse your position in it.
Total institutionGoffman
An organization that strips a self on admission and rebuilds it to its own specification: asylums, prisons, barracks, some schools.
Unknown knownsZizek
The things you do not know that you know. Beliefs you act on every day and have never once looked at directly. Usually the real target of any attempt to see clearly.
War of positionGramsci
The long struggle for cultural ground inside schools, media and publishing, as opposed to a frontal seizure of the state. You win the culture before you win the state.